Improved numerical simulation of the low temperature Fischer-Tropsch synthesis in a trickle bed reactor

Document Type: Full article


School of Chemical, Petroleum and Gas Engineering, Iran University of Science and Technology, P. O. Box: 16765-163, Tehran, Iran


Gas to liquid (GTL) process involves heterogeneous catalytic chemical reactions that convert synthesis gas to hydrocarbons and water vapor. A three phase reactor, called Low temperature Fischer-Tropsch (LTFT) is commonly applied for GTL process. In this reactor the gaseous phase includes the synthesis gas, light hydrocarbons and water vapor, the liquid phase is a mixture of the heavy hydrocarbons, and the solid phase is composed of the catalyst and the waxy products. The presence of the liquid phase in LTFT reactor causes mass transfer restriction, affecting the reaction conversion. In this work a numerical simulation of the LTFT fixed bed reactor in trickle flow regime has been accomplished to understand the impact of the liquid phase on the reactor performance. For this purpose, we have developed an axisymmetric two-dimensional multiphase heterogeneous model, where contain carbon monoxide and hydrogen, are transferred into the liquid phase. The reactor consisted of a shell and a tube that was filled with the spherical cobalt catalyst. The reaction conditions were as follows: the wall temperature was 473 K, pressure was 20 bars and a gas hour space velocity (GHSV) was 111 Nml.g_cat^(-1).h^(-1). The numerical simulation results proved the negative impact of the liquid phase on the reaction conversion. The model predictions were evaluated against the reported experimental data and also compared with the result of a numerical pseudo-homogeneous model. It was found that applying the heterogeneous model instead of the pseudo-homogeneous model clearly decreases the deviation of the numerical results.


Main Subjects

[1]      Hallac, B. B., K. K., Hedengren, J. D., Hecker, W. C. and Argyle, M. D., “An optimized simulation model for iron-based Fischer-Tropsch catalyst design: Transfer limitations as functions of operating and design conditions”, Chemical Engineering Journal, 263, 268 (2015).

[2]      Pandey, S. K., CFD simulation of hydrodynamics of three phase fluidized bed in chemical engineering, National Institute of Technology, Rourkela, India, (2010).

[3]      Guettel, T., R., “Comparison of different reactor types for low temperature Fischer-Tropsch synthesis: A simulation study”, Chemical Engineering Science, 64, 955 (2009).

[4]      Magoo, A. K., Mittal, A. and Roy, S., “Modeling packed bed Fischer-Tropsch reactors with phase evolution”, Indian Chemical Engineer, 55 (1), 29 (2013).

[5]      Rahimpour, M. R., H. E., “Optimization of a novel combination of fixed and fluidized-bed hydrogen-permselective membrane reactors for Fischer-Tropsch synthesis in GTL technology”, Chemical Engineering Journal, 152, 543 (2009).

[6]      Dai, X. P., et al., “Fischer-Tropsch synthesis in a bench-scale two-stage multitubular fixed-bed reactor: Simulation and enhancement in conversion and diesel selectivity”, Chemical Engineering Science, 105 (0), 1 (2014).

[7]      Atwood, H. E. and Bennett, C. O., “Kinetics of the Fischer-Tropsch reaction over iron”, Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Process Design and Development, 18 (1), 163 (1979).

[8]      Liu, Q. S., Z. X. Z., Zhou, J. L. and Zhang, B. J., “Heterogeneous modeling of fixed-bed Fischer-Tropsch synthesis: reactor model and It's applications”, Journal of Chemical Engineering Science, 58, 867 (2003).

[9]      Wang, Y. -N., et al., “Heterogeneous modeling for fixed-bed Fischer-Tropsch synthesis: Reactor model and its applications”, Chemical Engineering Science, 58 (3–6), 867 (2003).

[10]  Jess, A., R. P. and Hedden, K., “Fischer-Tropsch synthesis with nitrogen-rich syngas: Fundamentals and reactor design aspects”, Applied Catalysis, A: General, 186, 321 (1999).

[11]  Jess, A. and Kern, C., “Modeling of multi-tubular reactors for Fischer-Tropsch synthesis”, Chemical Engineering & Technology, 32 (8), 1164 (2009).

[12]  Lee, T. S., J. N. C., “Mathematical modeling and numerical simulation of a Fischer-Tropsch packed bed reactor and its thermal management for liquid hydrocarbon fuel production using biomass syngas”, Energy & Fuels, 26, 1363 (2012).

[13]  Knochen, J., et al., “Fischer-Tropsch synthesis in milli-structured fixed-bed reactors: Experimental study and scale-up considerations”, Chemical Engineering and Processing: Process Intensification, 49 (9), 958 (2010).

[14]  Brunner, K. M., H. D. P., Peguin, R. P. S., Duncan, J. C., Harrison, L. D., Bartholomew, C. H. and Hecker, W. C., “Effects of particle size and shape on the performance of a trickle fixed-bed recycle reactor for Fischer-Tropsch synthesis”, Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research, 54, 2902 (2015).

[15]  Lee, T. -S., Numerical modeling and simulation of Fischer-Tropsch packed bed reactor and its thermal managment, in Chemical Engineering, University of Florida, (2011).

[16]  Rytter, E., N. E. T. and Holmen, A., “On the selectivity to higher hydrocarbons in co-based Fischer-Tropsch synthesis”, Catalysis Today, 261, 3 (2015).

[17]  Vervloet, D., F. K., Nijenhuis, J. and van Ommen, J. R., “Fischer-Tropsch reaction-diffusion in a cobalt catalyst particle: aspects of activity and selectivity for a variable chain growth probability”, Catalysis Science and Technology, 2, 1221 (2012).

[18]  Benyahia, F., K. E. O. N., “Enhanced voidage correlations for packed beds of various particle shapes and sizes”, Particulate Science and Technology, 23, 169 (2005).

[19]  Fratalocchi, L., C. G. V., Lietti, L., Tronconi, E. and Rossini, S., “Exploiting the effects of mass transfer to boost the performances of Co/-Al2O3 eggshell catalysts for the Fischer-Tropsch synthesis”, Applied Catalysis, A: General, 512, 36 (2016).

[20]  Wang, Y. -N., et al., “Modeling of catalyst pellets for Fischer-Tropsch synthesis”, Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research, 40 (20), 4324 (2001).

[21]  Visconti, C. G., E. T., Groppi, G., Lietti, L., Iovane, M., Rossini, S. and Zennaro, R., “Monolithic catalysts with high thermal conductivity for the Fischer-Tropsch synthesis in tubular reactors”, Chemical Engineering Journal, 171, 1294 (2011).

[22]  Brunner, K. M., J. C. D., Harrison, L. D., Pratt, K. E., Peguin, R. P. S., Bartholomew, C. H. and Hecker, W. C., “A trickle fixed-bed recycle reactor model for the Fischer-Tropsch synthesis”, International Journal of Chemical Reactor Engineering, 10, (2012).

[23]  Rafiq, M. H., H. A. J., Schmid, R. and Hustad, J. E., “Experimental studies and modeling of a fixed bed reactor for Fischer-Tropsch synthesis using biosyngas”, Fuel Processing Technology, 92, 893 (2011).

[24]  Ermolaev, V. S., K. O. G., Mitberg, E. B., Mordkovich, V. Z. and Tretyakov, V. F., “Laboratory and pilot plant fixed-bed reactors for Fischer-Tropsch synthesis: Mathematical modeling and experimental investigation”, Chemical Engineering Science, 138, 1 (2015).

[25]  Steynberg, A. P. D., M. E., Davis, B. H. and Breman, B. B., “Fischer-Tropsch reactors”, Studies in Surface and Catalysis, 152, (2004).

[26]  Kamali, M. R., A lattice Boltzmann approach to multi-phase surface reactions with heat effects, Technische Universiteit Delft, (2013).

[27]  Ahmadi Marvast, M., M. S., Zarrinpashneh, S. and Baghmisheh, G. R.,“Fischer-Tropsch synthesis: Modeling and performance study for Fe-HZSM5 bifunctional catalyst”, Chemical Engineering Technology, 28 (1), (2005).

[28]  Philippe, R. M. L., Dreibine, L., Huu, C. P., Edouard, D., Savin, S. and Luck, F., “Effect of structure and thermal properties of a Fischer-Tropsch catalyst in a fixed bed”, Catal. Today, 147, 305 (2009).