Comparison of Different Methods (Digestion, Combustion, Gasification and Pyrolysis) for Sludge Energy Recovery: A Case Study for Ekbatan’s Municipal Treatment Plant

Document Type: Full article


Petroleum and Chemical Engineering Department, Science and Research Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran


Different methods of urban sewage sludge energy recovery such as burning, gasification, pyrolysis and digestion based on the net energy production efficiency, advantages and disadvantages and complexity of these processes have been investigated in this article. The best method for energy production from sludge was selected among different methods according to energy and the amount of the greenhouse gas production. The capacity of the constructed power plant was calculated and investigated economically for each scenario. Quantitative and qualitative information on sludge was required to carry out this research so Ekbatan wastewater treatment sludge was analyzed. The results showed that the sludge of this treatment plant has 5.7% solids, containing 65.7% volatiles and the dry heat value is about 15100 kJ/kg. It was found that the best scenario for sludge energy production in this treatment plant is a digestion process with pure net energy production of 73.2 × 107 kJ/d. The energy recovery in an anaerobic digester can prevent the emission of 16,680 tons of CO2 annually and release about 1,460 tons of CO2 per year. The chemical analysis shows that the selected sludge has a potential production of 25m3 of CH4 for each m3 of sludge. The annual amount of biogas that can be recovered from municipal treatment plant is 836543 m3. On the other hand, the biogas can be used to generate electricity. The power of the plant is about 216.8 kW that with the construction of this power plant, an annual saving of 1.5 million dollars will occur.


Main Subjects

[1]      American Public Health Association, American Water Works Association and Water Environment Federation, “Standard methods for the examination of water and wastewater standard”, (1999).

[2]      Sokhansanj, S., “The effect of moisture on heating values”, Biomass Energy Data Book, No. C, 1 (2011).

[3]      Turovskiy, I. S. and Mathai, P. K., Wastewater sludge processing, John Wiley & Sons, Florida, USA, (2006).

[4]      Provenzano, M. R., Daniela Malerba, A., Buscaroli, A., Zannoni, D. and Senesi, N., “Anaerobic digestion of municipal solid waste and sewage sludge under mesophilic and thermophilic conditions: A thermal study in DSC associated to infrared spectroscopy”, J. Therm. Anal. Calorim., 111 (3), 1861 (2013).

[5]      Azlina, W. a N., Ab, W. a N., Ghani, K. and Idris, A., “Preliminary study on biogas production of biogas from municipal solid waste (MSW) leachate”, Engineering Science and Technology, 4 (4), 374 (2009).

[6]      Çalli, B., “Energy production from wastewater”, Proceedings of Istanbul International Solid Waste, Water and Wastewater Congres, Istanbul, Turkey, (2013).

[7]      Andersen, A., “Disposal and recycling routes for sewage sludge: Part 3-scientific and technical report”, Luxembourg, (2001).

[8]      Cao, Y. and Pawłowski, A., “Energy sustainability of two parallel sewage sludge-to-energy pathways: Effect of sludge volatile solids content on net energy efficiency”, Environ. Prot. Eng., 38 (2), 77 (2012).

[9]      Zhang, L., Xu, C. (Charles) and Champagne, P., “Energy recovery from secondary pulp/paper-mill sludge and sewage sludge with supercritical water treatment”, Bioresour. Technol., 101 (8), 2713 (2010).

[10]  Hagelqvist, A., “Forest industry sludge as a resource for energy recovery”, Licentiate thesis, Karlstad University, (2009).

[11]  Andersen, A., “Disposal and recycling routes for sewage sludge: Part 3-scientific and sub-component”, Luxembourg, (2001).

[12]  Kim, Y. and Parker, W., “A technical and economic evaluation of the pyrolysis of sewage sludge for the production of bio-oil”, Bioresour. Technol., 99 (5), 1409 (2008).

[13]  Pandey, S., Baral, B., Karki, S. and Upreti, A., “Prediction of syngas composition from biomass gasification using thermodynamics equilibrium model”, Rentech Symp. Compend., 3, 5 (2013).

[14]  Vaezi, M. and Passandideh-Fard, M., “Modeling biomass gasification: A new approach to utilize renewable sources of energy”, Proceedings of ASME International Mechanical Engineering Congress and Exposition, (2008).

[15]  Vaezi, M. and Passandideh-Fard, M., “Modeling biomass gasification: A new approach to utilize renewable sources of energy”, Proceedings of National Mechanical Engineering Congress and Exposition, (2008).

[16]  Tissandier, M. D. et al., “The prot’s absolute aqueous enthalpy and Gibbs free energy of solvation from cluster-Ion solvation data”, J. Phys. Chem. A, 102, (40), 7787 (1998).

[17]  Tasma, D., Panait, T., Jos, D. and St, D., “The quality of syngas produced by fluidised bed gasification using sunflower husk”, 33 (2012).

[18]  EPA Technology Assessment Report, “Aqueous sludge gasification technologies”, (June 2012).

[19]  Cao, Y. and Pawlowski, A., “Sewage sludge-to-energy approaches based on anaerobic digestion and pyrolysis: Brief overview and energy efficiency assessment”, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 16 (3), 1657 (2012).

[20]  Caballero, J. a., Front, R., Marcilla, A. and Conesa, J. a., “Characterization of sewage sludges by primary and secondary pyrolysis”, J. Anal. Appl. Pyrolysis, 40-41, 433 (1997).

[21]  Samii, R., “The feasibility of producing electricity from the latex gas from Aradkouh”, Master's Degree in Tehran University, (1389).

[22]  Metcalf & Eddy, Wastewater engineering, treatment, disposal and reuse, 4th ed., McGraw-Hill Inc., (2003).